| Name | Gender | Vocal Part | Age Range | Role Type |
| Carlton Smith | male | 40 – 50 | supporting | |
| Father Federico | male | N/A | ||
| Father Tommaso | male | N/A | ||
| Flo Braddock | female | N/A | ||
| Gia Campbell | female | 16 – 19 | supporting | |
| Katherine Smith | female | N/A | ||
| Mayor Nunzio Manzoni | male | N/A | ||
| Mildred Karzinski | female | N/A | ||
| Robert Bonafaccio | male | N/A | ||
| Rosa | female | supporting | ||
| Salvatore | male | N/A | ||
| Signora Berardi | female | N/A | ||
| Signora Carmelina Campbell | female | 40 – 50 | lead | |
| Steve Karzinski | male | 40 – 50 | supporting | |
| Vittorio Bruno | male | lead | ||
| Walter Braddock | male | 40 – 50 | supporting |