Act One

  • "Another Hot Day" - File and Townspeople
  • "Lizzie's Coming Home" - H.C. Curry, Noah Curry, and Jimmy Curry
  • "Love, Don't Turn Away" - Lizzie Curry
  • "Poker Polka" - File, H.C. Curry, Noah Curry, and Jimmy Curry
  • "The Hungry Men" - Lizzie Curry and Townspeople
  • "The Rain Song" - Bill Starbuck and Townspeople
  • "You're Not Foolin' Me" - Bill Starbuck and Lizzie Curry
  • "Cinderella" - Vivian Lorraine Taylor and Lizzie Curry
  • "Raunchy" - Lizzie Curry
  • "A Man and a Woman" - File and Lizzie Curry
  • "Old Maid" - Lizzie Curry

Act Two

  • "Evenin' Star" (added for the 2007 revival) - Bill Starbuck
  • "Everything Beautiful Happens at Night" - Lizzie Curry and Townspeople
  • "Melisande" - Bill Starbuck
  • "Simple Little Things" - Lizzie Curry
  • "Little Red Hat" - Snookie and Jimmy Curry
  • "Is It Really Me?" - Lizzie Curry
  • "Wonderful Music" - Bill Starbuck, File, and Lizzie Curry
  • "The Rain Song" (Reprise) - Townspeople

A song with an asterisk (*) before the title indicates a dance number.