Act One

  • Overture - Orchestra
  • Storybook - Marguerite & Ensemble
  • Madame Guillotine - Chauvelin, St. Cyr & Ensemble
  • You Are My Home, Wedding Dance, Prayer - Percy, Marguerite & Ensemble
  • Prayer - Percy
  • Into The Fire - Percy, Armand, Ozzy, Dewhurst, Elton, Farleigh, Hal & Ben
  • Falcon in the Dive - Chauvelin
  • Scarlet Pimpernel Transition - Percy, Marie, Marguerite & Girls
  • When I Look At You - Marguerite
  • When I Look At You (Reprise) - Percy & Marguerite
  • Where's The Girl? - Chauvelin
  • You Are My Home (Garden Reprise) - Marguerite & Armand
  • The Creation of Man - Percy, Ozzy, Dewhurst, Elton, Farleigh, Hal & Ben
  • Marguerite's Dilemma - Orchestra
  • The Riddle - Chauvelin, Marguerite, Percy & Ensemble

Act Two

  • Opening Act II - Percy, Marguerite & Ensemble
  • The Scarlet Pimpernel - Orchestra
  • They Seek Him Here - Percy, Marguerite, Chauvelin, Elton, Farleigh, Dewhurst, Ozzy, Prince of Wales & Ensemble
  • Ouilles Gavotte - Orchestra
  • She Was There - Percy
  • Storybook (Bistro Reprise) - Marguerite & Ensemble
  • Where's The Girl? (Reprise) - Chauvelin
  • Into The Fire (Reprise) - Ozzy, Dewhurst, Farleigh, Elton, Hal & Ben
  • I'll Forget You - Marguerite
  • The Duel - Orchestra
  • Finale/When I Look At You (Reprise) - Marguerite, Percy & Ensemble
  • Bows/Into The Fire (Reprise) - Percy & Company

Editor’s Note: Major changes were made to the song list after the musical opened on Broadway in 1998. This song list reflects the current production.

A song with an asterisk (*) before the title indicates a dance number.