Act One

  • The Avenue Q Theme – Company
  • What Do You Do with a B.A. in English? – Princeton
  • If You Were Gay – Nicky with Rod
  • Purpose – Princeton and Company (via "singing boxes")
  • Everyone's a Little Bit Racist – Princeton, Kate, Gary, Brian, and Christmas Eve
  • My Social Life Is Online – Kate, Trekkie Monster, Brian, Gary Coleman, Rod, and Princeton
  • A Mix Tape – Kate and Princeton
  • I'm Not Wearing Underwear Today – Brian
  • Special – Lucy
  • Fantasies Come True – Rod, Kate, Nicky and Princeton
  • There's a Fine, Fine Line – Kate

Act Two

  • There Is Life Outside Your Apartment – Brian, Princeton, Christmas Eve, Gary, Nicky, Trekkie Monster, Lucy, and Company
  • The More You Ruv Someone – Christmas Eve and Kate
  • Schadenfreude – Gary and Nicky
  • I Wish I Could Go Back to College – Kate, Nicky and Princeton
  • The Money Song – Nicky, Princeton, Gary, Brian and Christmas Eve
  • The Money Song (Reprise) – Nicky, Princeton, Gary, Brian and Christmas Eve
  • There's a Fine, Fine Line (Reprise) – Princeton and Kate
  • What Do You Do With a B.A. in English? (Reprise) – Newcomer
  • For Now – Company

A song with an asterisk (*) before the title indicates a dance number.