Act One

  • *Christmastown - Buddy, Ensemble
  • World's Greatest Dad - Buddy
  • In the Way - Deb, Walter, Emily, Michael, Ensemble
  • *Sparklejollytwinklejingley - Buddy, Store Manager, Ensemble
  • I'll Believe in You - Michael, Emily
  • In the Way [Reprise] - Emily, Walter
  • Just Like Him - Buddy, Deb, Ensemble
  • *A Christmas Song - Buddy, Jovie, Ensemble
  • World's Greatest Dad [Reprise] - Buddy

Act Two

  • Nobody Cares About Santa - Buddy, Store Manager, Ensemble
  • Never Fall in Love (With an Elf) - Jovie
  • There Is a Santa Claus - Michael, Emily
  • The Story of Buddy - Buddy, Michael, Walter, Ensemble
  • Nobody Cares About Santa [Reprise] - Santa
  • *A Christmas Song [Reprise] - Jovie, Buddy, Emily, Michael, Walter, Ensemble
  • *Finale - Ensemble

A song with an asterisk (*) before the title indicates a dance number.