Act One

  • Epiphany — Company
  • You & I — Jason, Peter and Students
  • Role of a Lifetime — Peter
  • Auditions — Sister Chantelle & Students
  • Plain Jane Fat Ass — Nadia & Jason
  • Wonderland — Lucas & Students
  • A Quiet Night at Home — Nadia
  • Rolling — Peter, Jason, Matt and Lucas
  • Best Kept Secret — Jason & Peter
  • Confession — Priest & Students
  • Portrait of a Girl — Ivy & Matt
  • Birthday, Bitch! — Students
  • One Kiss — Ivy & Jason
  • Are You There? — Matt & Peter
  • 911! Emergency! — Virgin Mary & Cherubs
  • Reputation Stain'd — Students
  • Ever After — Peter & Jason
  • Spring — Nadia
  • One — Ivy, Jason, Nadia, Matt and Peter

Act Two

  • Wedding Bells — Company
  • In The Hallway — Students
  • Touch My Soul — Ivy & Jason
  • See Me — Peter & Claire
  • Warning — Claire
  • Pilgrim's Hands — Jason, Peter and Students
  • God Don't Make No Trash — Sister Chantelle
  • All Grown Up — Ivy
  • Promise — Jason, Ivy, Matt, Peter and Nadia
  • Once Upon a Time — Jason
  • Cross — Jason & Priest
  • Two Households — Students
  • Bare — Jason & Peter
  • Queen Mab — Peter
  • A Glooming Peace — Students
  • Absolution — Peter
  • No Voice — Company

A song with an asterisk (*) before the title indicates a dance number.