Act One

  • "So Many Nights" - Homer, Marjorie, Stella, Andy, Hope & Dave
  • "Diva" - Hope, Dave & Andy
  • "Every Day Is Night" - Julia
  • "Somebody" - Wood & Company
  • "Coming True" - Homer & Julia
  • "It's Only a Play" - Homer & Company
  • "She's Out There" - Andy
  • "Birds of Paradise" - Marjorie, Stella & Hope
  • "Imagining You" - Company

Act Two

  • "Penguins Must Sing" - Dave, Hope & Andy
  • "You're Mine" - Marjorie
  • "Things I Can't Forget" - Homer & Marjorie
  • "After Opening Night" - Homer & Marjorie
  • "Chekhov" - Company
  • "Something New" - Company

A song with an asterisk (*) before the title indicates a dance number.