Act One

  • "A Very Special Day" – Jeanie and trio
  • "That's the Way It Happens" – Jeanie and trio
  • "That's the Way It Happens" (Reprise) – Larry
  • "* Dance Impromptu" – Chorus, George, and trio
  • "Overture to Me and Juliet" – Dario and orchestra
  • "* Opening of Me and Juliet" – Lily, Jim, Susie, and Charlie
  • "* Marriage Type Love" – Charlie, Lily, and singers
  • "Keep It Gay" – Bob, Jim, and chorus
  • "* Keep it Gay" (Reprise) – Betty and Buzz
  • "The Big Black Giant" – Larry
  • "No Other Love" – Jeanie and Larry
  • "* Dance" – Ralph, Francine, and Elizabeth
  • "The Big Black Giant" (Reprise) – Ruby
  • "It's Me" – Betty and Jeanie
  • "* First Act Finale" – Lily, Betty, Charlie, Jim, Jeanie, and chorus

Act Two

  • "Intermission Talk" – Herbie and chorus
  • "It Feels Good" – Bob
  • "* We Deserve Each Other" – Betty, Jim, and dancers
  • "I'm Your Girl" – Jeanie and Larry
  • "* Second Act Finale" – Charlie, Lily, Betty, Jim, and chorus
  • "Finale" – Company

A song with an asterisk (*) before the title indicates a dance number.