ACT ONE

  • On the Side of Angels - Neil
  • On the Side of Angels - Morris
  • Angels Counter - Marie, Neil, Morris, Zapatella, Lopez, Mrs. Pomerantz
  • Politics and Poker - Ben and Ben’s Poker Buddies
  • Unfair #1 - Dora and Girls
  • Unfair (Fiorello’s Version) - Fiorello and Girls
  • Marie’s Law - Marie and Morris
  • *The Name’s LaGuardia - Fiorello and Ensemble
  • The Bum Won - Ben and Ben’s Poker Buddies
  • I Love a Cop - Dora
  • *Cop Dance - Dora
  • I Love a Cop (Reprise) - Dora, Floyd and Ensemble
  • Till Tomorrow - Thea, Marie, Morris and Ensemble
  • Home Again (Finale Act 1) - Ensemble

ACT TWO

  • When Did I Fall in Love - Thea
  • *Gentleman Jimmy - Mitzi and Mitzi’s Dancers
  • Gentleman Jim (Reprise) - Ensemble
  • Fiorello Crossover - Fiorello
  • Little Tin Box - Ben and Ben’s Poker Buddies
  • The Very Next Man - Marie
  • Politics and Poker (Reprise) - Men
  • Very Next Man (Reprise - Finale Act 2) - Marie, Men, and Fiorello

A song with an asterisk (*) before the title indicates a dance number.