Act One

  • "Belmont Avenue" – Calogero and Ensemble
  • "Look to Your Heart" – Lorenzo and Young Calogero
  • "Roll 'Em" – Sonny, Young Calogero and Ensemble
  • "I Like It" – Young Calogero and Ensemble
  • "Giving Back the Money" – Lorenzo, Young Calogero, Rosina and Sonny
  • "I Like It (Reprise)" – Calogero, Young Calogero, Sonny and Ensemble
  • "Ain't It The Truth" – Calogero and Male Ensemble
  • "Out of Your Head" – Calogero, Jane, Denise, Frieda, and Ensemble
  • "Nicky Machiavelli" – Sonny and Male Ensemble
  • "These Streets" – Lorenzo, Sonny, Rosina and Ensemble

Act Two

  • "Webster Avenue" – Jane, Calogero, Tyrone, Jesse, Denise and Frieda
  • "Out of Your Head (Reprise)" – Jane
  • "One of the Great Ones" – Sonny
  • "Ain't It The Truth (Reprise)" – Tyrone and Jesse
  • "Look to Your Heart (Reprise)" – Rosina
  • "One of the Great Ones (Reprise)" – Calogero
  • "Hurt Someone" – Tyrone, Calogero, and, Ensemble
  • "In a World Like This" – Calogero, Jane and Ensemble
  • "The Choices We Make" – Calogero, Lorenzo, Jane, Rosina, Company

A song with an asterisk (*) before the title indicates a dance number.