Act One

  • "Live Like This”- Mae, Winnie, Angus, Jesse, Miles, Man in the Yellow Suit, Ensemble
  • "Good Girl, Winnie Foster” - Winnie, Mothers
  • “Join the Parade" - Man in the Yellow Suit, Fair Musicians
  • “Good Girl, Winnie Foster (Reprise)" - Winnie
  • "Top of the World" - Jesse, Winnie
  • "Hugo's First Case" - Hugo
  • "Story of the Tucks" - Mae, Jesse, Miles
  • “My Most Beautiful Day” - Mae, Angus, Ensemble
  • "The Attic" - Winnie
  • "Join the Parade (Reprise)” - Man in the Yellow Suit, Ensemble
  • "Partner in Crime" - Winnie, Jesse, Ensemble
  • "Seventeen” - Jesse, Winnie, Man in the Yellow Suit, Ensemble

Act Two

  • "Everything’s Golden" - Man in the Yellow Suit, Ensemble
  • "Seventeen (Reprise)” - Winnie
  • "Time" - Miles
  • "Time (Reprise)" - Miles, Mae, Angus, Jesse
  • "Everything's Golden (Reprise)” - Man in the Yellow Suit
  • "You Can’t Trust a Man" - Constable Joe, Hugo
  • "The Wheel" - Angus, Winnie
  • "Story of the Man in the Yellow Suit" - Man in the Yellow Suit
  • "Everlasting” - Winnie
  • "The Story of Winnie Foster" - Orchestra
  • "The Wheel (Reprise)” - Jesse, Ensemble

A song with an asterisk (*) before the title indicates a dance number.