- Overture – Orchestra
- The Prince Is Giving a Ball – Herald and Chorus
- Cinderella March – Orchestra
- In My Own Little Corner – Cinderella
- The Prince Is Giving a Ball (reprise) – Chorus
- Your Majesties (Royal Dressing Room Scene) – King, Queen, Chef and Steward
- In My Own Little Corner (reprise) – Cinderella
- Impossible; It's Possible – Cinderella and Fairy Godmother
- When You're Driving Through the Moonlight – Cinderella, Stepmother and Stepsisters
- A Lovely Night – Cinderella, Stepmother and Stepsisters
- The Search – Orchestra
- Do I Love You Because You're Beautiful? (Reprise) – Prince
- Wedding – Orchestra
- Do I Love You Because You're Beautiful? (Reprise) – Chorus
Unlike the three-act television version, the 2013 Broadway production is performed in two acts with additional songs, including "Me, Who Am I?", "Now Is the Time" (cut from South Pacific), "The Pursuit", "Loneliness of Evening" (cut from South Pacific, and featured in the 1965 broadcast), and "There's Music in You".
A song with an asterisk (*) before the title indicates a dance number; a character listed in a song with an asterisk (*) by the character's name indicates that the character exclusively serves as a dancer in this song, which is sung by other characters.