Act 1 1. Cantata for a First Date - Company 2. Not Tonight, I'm Busy, Busy, Busy- Melissa and Jordan 3. A Stud and a Babe- Robert and Jennifer 4. Single Man Drought – Jennifer and Melissa 5. Why? 'Cause I'm a Guy – Robert and Jordan 6. Tear Jerk – Jordan and Melissa 7. The Lasagna Incident- Jennifer and Robert 8. I Will Be Loved Tonight – Jennifer 9. And Now the Parents – Company 10. Hey There, Single Gal/Guy – Jordan, Jennifer 11. Satisfaction Guaranteed – Company 12. He Called Me – Jennifer, Company 13. Cantata Reprise #1/Wedding Vows – Company
Act 2 14. Cantata Reprise #2 – Robert and Jennifer 15. Always a Bridesmaid – Melissa 16. The Baby Song – Jordan 17. *Marriage Tango – Robert and Melissa 18. On the Highway of Love – Company 19. Waiting Trio – Melissa, Robert, Jennifer 20. Cantata Reprise #3- Jordan, Jennifer 21. Shouldn't I Be Less In Love With You? – Robert 22. I Can Live With That – Jordan and Melissa 23. I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change – Finale The current licensed version available for production includes a new song in Act I, Scene 2. The song "We Had It All" was added during the Off-Broadway run and was part of several tours of the show.
A song with an asterisk (*) before the title indicates a dance number; a character listed in a song with an asterisk (*) by the character's name indicates that the character exclusively serves as a dancer in this song, which is sung by other characters.