Act One

  • Beautiful - Veronica and Students
  • Candy Store - Heather Chandler, Heather Duke, and Heather McNamara (the Heathers)
  • Fight For Me - Veronica and Students
  • Candy Store Playoff - the Heathers
  • Freeze Your Brain - JD
  • Big Fun - Ram, Kurt, Veronica, the Heathers, and Students
  • Dead Girl Walking - Veronica and JD
  • *Veronica’s Chandler Nightmare - Heather Chandler and Students
  • The Me Inside of Me - Heather Chandler, Veronica, Cops, Ms. Fleming, and Company
  • Blue - Heather McNamara, Heather Duke, Kurt, and Ram
  • Blue Reprise - Heather McNamara, Heather Duke, Kurt, Ram, and Students
  • ~Blue Playoff - Students
  • Our Love Is God - Veronica and JD

Act Two

  • ~Prom or Hell?- Veronica
  • My Dead Gay Son- Ram’s Dad, Kurt’s Dad, and Mourners
  • Seventeen- Veronica and JD
  • Shine A Light- Ms. Fleming and Students
  • Lifeboat- Heather McNamara
  • Shine A Light Reprise- Heather Duke and Students
  • ~Hey, Yo Westerberg- Heather McNamara and Students
  • Kindergarten Boyfriend- Martha
  • Yo Girl- Heather Chandler, Ram and Kurt
  • Meant To Be Yours- JD and Students
  • Dead Girl Walking Reprise- Veronica, JD, and Students
  • I Am Damaged- Veronica and JD
  • Seventeen Reprise- Veronica, Martha, Heather McNamara, and Company

~Not featured on the world premiere cast recording.

A song with an asterisk (*) before the title indicates a dance number.