Act One

  • "At the Music Hall" — Harry and Ensemble
  • "Charlotte Sweet" — Bob, Charlotte, and Ensemble
  • "A Daughter of Valentine's Day" — Charlotte and Ensemble
  • "Forever" — Ludlow and Charlotte
  • "Liverpool Sunset" — Ensemble
  • "Layers of Underwear" — Bob, Katinka, Barnaby, and Charlotte
  • "Quartet Agonistes" — Katinka, Barnaby, Charlotte, and Bob
  • "Forever (Reprise)" — Barnaby and Katinka
  • "The Circus of Voices" — Barnaby, Katinka, Skitzy, Cecily, Harry, and Charlotte
  • "Keep It Low" — Katinka and Men’s Chorus (Harry and Skitzy)
  • "Bubbles In Me Bonnet" — Cecily
  • "Vegetable Reggie" — Harry
  • "My Baby and Me" — Skitzy
  • "A-Weaving" — Charlotte
  • "Your High Note!" — Charlotte, Barnaby, and Katinka
  • "Katinka/The Darkness" — Barnaby

Act Two

  • "On It Goes" – Bob and Ensemble
  • "You See In Me a Bobby" – “Patrick”, Barnaby, and Katinka
  • "A Christmas Bûche" – Charlotte, Cecily, Skitzy, and Harry
  • "The Letter (Me Charlotte Dear)" – Ludlow
  • "Dover" – Skitzy
  • "Volley of Indecision" – Skitzy, Harry, and Charlotte
  • "Good Things Come" – Cecily
  • "It Could Only Happen In the Theatre" – Cecily, Skitzy, “Patrick,” and Harry
  • "Lonely Canary" – Charlotte
  • "Queenly Comments" – “The Queen,” Barnaby, Katinka, “Patrick,” and Charlotte
  • "Surprise! Surprise!" – Ensemble
  • "The Reckoning" – Ensemble
  • "Farewell to Auld Lang Syne/Finale" – Ensemble

A song with an asterisk (*) before the title indicates a dance number.